export svg into inkscape

[thegavs]

OS: Linux Mint 16 Petra
Platform: 64-bit
Version: 0.13.1830 (Git)
Branch: releases/FreeCAD-0-13
Hash: ec7636d7aaf2612e9b43cff5d6a424037d53e505
Python version: 2.7.5+
Qt version: 4.8.4
Coin version: 4.0.0a
SoQt version: 1.5.0
OCC version: 6.5.4

I have noticed some thing strange when exporting a sketch from freecad into inkscape. The imported sketch into inkscape is slightly underscale.

For example a simple sketch of a 30mm square will around 29mm when imported into inkscape. Not sure of where the problem lies could be freecad or inkscape.

attched is a screen shot of inkscape. the black square is imported from freecad the red square drawn in inkscape showing the differance.

30mm square red is inkscape black freecad import

snapshot1.jpeg (121.91 KiB) Viewed 6533 times

any ideas on how to get the import to be exactly to scale?

Thanks

Gavin

[NormandC]

Have you checked the object properties to make sure of its dimensions? Might it not be that the imported object has an outline width of zero?

[triplus]

After quick test i would say size depends on 3D view zoom factor? If that is true maybe there is a trick where you could set it to "1:1". If not i would guess you will have to do re-scaling in Inkscape.

[ulrich1a]

The most reliable method is to create a view in a Drawing page with a template and save this page. The objects in the drawing have the original dimension in mm also in inkscape, if the scale is set correct.

Exporting an object as Flat-svg adds a margin of 1% or something around the object.

Ulrich

[thegavs]

would this be a bug or a feature? I think its a bug as the 1 percent seems random

[ulrich1a]

would this be a bug or a feature? I think its a bug as the 1 percent seems random

It is at least intentionally encoded in the Draft workbench code for the export of a flattened SVG.
It may be usefull for printing that object, but I see also a disadvantage in using it for other purposes.

Ulrich

[shoogen]

It may be usefull for printing that object, but I see also a disadvantage in using it for other purposes.

We got different modes of SVG export for different purposes.
Exporting the 3D view, will probably break the scale.
The flattened SVG output has two modes. One for display and printing and one for CAM. Both try to keep the scale. The latter one keeps the the absolute position as well.
Export of the a drawing is yet another mode of SVG output.
I'm willing to improve the SVG exporter. But I need to know what you are trying to achieve with the SVG.

[ulrich1a]

The flattened SVG output has two modes. One for display and printing and one for CAM.

I was not aware of the two modes. How would I get the CAM output mode? Is there a switch somewhere?

The flattened SVG without margin or even better with a user defined size in the export dialog has advantages, if you want to combine several of them in one technical SVG-drawing. I like also to try to define hatching patterns with a mm-scale. Those should have advantages in cases were the hatching needs to be scaled by millimeters.
It opens also the way to define SVG-symbols for drawings directly in FreeCAD.

Ulrich

[shoogen]

The flattened SVG output has two modes. One for display and printing and one for CAM.

I was not aware of the two modes. How would I get the CAM output mode? Is there a switch somewhere?

It is in the Draft Preferences http://www.freecadweb.org/wiki/index.ph ... references

[yorik]

This makes me think we really should do something about these import/export formats one day... Users are usually not aware of which module which exporter belongs to, so finding documentation and preferences can be hard... But that's a subject for a separate thread.